Trust and Estate Counsel

Tennessee Estate Planning Law

Insight and commentary on estate planning issues impacting affluent residents of Tennessee

Ask Your Spouse to Sign Your Buy-Sell Agreement

When you own a business with one or more other persons, it is advisable to enter into a written agreement with the other owners. These agreements have different names depending upon the type of entity: shareholder agreements for corporations, partnership agreements for limited partnerships and general partnerships; and operating agreements for limited liability companies. These agreements are sometimes generically referred to as “Buy-Sell Agreements”.

Buy-Sell Agreements typically restrict transfers to third parties and specify rights of the parties under certain circumstances such as death, divorce and disability. It is not uncommon for these agreements to give the company and/or the other owners an option to buy your interest in the company for a predetermined price in the event that you die, or become disabled, or transfer your stock to any other person, including your spouse upon divorce. The price is generally less than a proportionate share of the value of the entire business.

If a divorce court awards a portion of your interest in the company to your spouse, your spouse may contend that he or she is not bound by the Buy-Sell Agreement. Alternatively, your spouse may argue that your interest in the company should be valued based upon the different method than that contained in the Buy-Sell Agreement.

Customarily, spouses do not sign Buy-Sell Agreements unless they own an interest in the company. However, a recent case decided by the Tennessee Court of Appeals provides a good reason for asking your spouse to sign the Buy-Sell Agreement.

In the Inzer (pdf) case, the wife argued that her husband’s stock in his company should not be valued in accordance with a formula contained in the Buy-Sell Agreement. The Court indicated that the wife’s argument would have been meritorious if she had not signed the Buy-Sell Agreement. Because she signed the Agreement, the Court ruled that she was bound by the valuation formula.

For purposes of valuing the couples' marital estate, the stock was valued significantly below its pro rata share of the total value of the company. Because the husband was awarded the stock, this meant that the wife received a smaller share of the other assets. As a result of this case, I plan to recommend that my clients ask their spouses to sign their Buy-Sell Agreements.